TL;DR
If your Dallas or Collin County appraisal looks too high, you can protest to the appraisal review board. File by May 15 or 30 days after your notice arrives, whichever is later. You can protest the value, unequal appraisal and denied exemptions. Ask for the district's evidence, bring your own, and know that for a value protest the district carries the burden of proof.
What you can protest
Tax Code section 41.41 lists what a property owner can protest to the appraisal review board. The most common grounds are:
- The appraised value of your property is too high.
- Unequal appraisal, meaning your property is valued higher than comparable properties.
- Denial of a partial exemption, such as a homestead exemption.
- Inclusion of property on the records that should not be there, or the wrong taxing units.
The appraisal review board, or ARB, is a panel of local residents separate from the appraisal staff. In our area you deal with the Dallas Central Appraisal District or the Collin Central Appraisal District and their ARBs. Each district publishes its own protest instructions.
The deadline
Under section 41.44, you must file a written notice of protest by May 15 or the 30th day after your appraisal notice was delivered, whichever is later. Other deadlines apply to some changes, such as a determination that the use of agricultural land changed.
Do not wait for the tax bill in the fall. By then the protest window has usually closed. If your notice was not delivered, ask the appraisal district about your options right away.
Who has to prove what
Two rules help owners:
- The burden is on the district. Section 41.43 says that in a protest of value or unequal appraisal, the appraisal district must establish the value by a preponderance of the evidence. If it does not, the protest is decided in the owner's favor. A stricter standard applies in some cases, for example when the owner brings a qualifying recent appraisal on a property valued at $1 million or less.
- You can see their evidence. Section 41.461 says that at least 14 days before the hearing, the chief appraiser must tell you that you can request the data, schedules, formulas and other information the district will use at the hearing. The district cannot charge you for those copies.
Ask for the evidence in writing, early
Request the district's hearing evidence as soon as you file. It shows the comparable sales or land rates they used, which tells you what you need to answer.
Building a value case for a house
Texas is a non-disclosure state, so sale prices are not public record. That makes your evidence more important. Useful items:
- Condition evidence. Dated photos of foundation cracks, roof leaks, water damage or old systems, with contractor bids for the repairs.
- A recent appraisal from a licensed appraiser, if you have one.
- Comparable properties. Similar homes nearby with lower appraised values support an unequal appraisal claim. Closed sales from an agent's MLS search support a market value claim.
- Your own purchase. If you bought recently in an arm's-length sale, your closing statement is strong evidence.
Our guide to valuing property without public sale prices explains how investors and appraisers work around non-disclosure.
Building a value case for a lot
Appraisal districts often value land from neighborhood schedules: a rate per square foot, per front foot or per acre. That works for typical lots and can miss the problems that make a lot worth less. Look for:
- Floodplain or drainage issues. Check FEMA maps and city drainage records. See our guide to floodplain and drainage checks.
- Shape and access. A narrow, landlocked or irregular lot may be valued like a regular one.
- Utilities. No sewer tap or a long water line extension costs money. Our utility checks guide covers what to look for.
- Easements and setbacks that shrink the buildable area.
If you are deciding whether to keep or sell the lot, our guide to what a lot is worth explains the three pricing methods. The glossary entry on CAD market value explains why appraisal values lag the market.
The steps
- File a notice of protest on time. File with the appraisal review board by May 15 or 30 days after your notice was delivered, whichever is later. DCAD takes most protests online through its uFile system, using the PIN printed on your appraisal notice. For Collin County, check collincad.org for the current filing options.
- Request the district's evidence. Ask for the data, schedules and formulas it will use at your hearing.
- Build your value case. Gather photos, repair bids, a recent appraisal, comparable properties and anything that lowers value.
- Talk to the appraiser informally. Many protests settle in an informal meeting before the formal hearing. You can accept a settlement or go to the ARB.
- Present at the hearing. If you do not settle, present your evidence to the ARB panel. Keep it short and organized: the value you want and the three or four facts that support it.
If you disagree with the ARB's decision, Texas law provides further appeal options, including district court and, for some properties, binding arbitration or the State Office of Administrative Hearings. Those have their own deadlines and costs. Ask a property tax consultant or attorney.
For a look at how Dallas County values have moved, see our Dallas County land market pages and the Collin County hub.
RBSHome buys homes and lots as-is in Dallas and Collin County, including Plano and Garland. If a high appraisal is one more reason you are thinking about selling, we can give you a written offer to compare.
This article is general information, not legal or tax advice. Talk to your appraisal district, a licensed property tax consultant or a Texas attorney about your property.
Written offer, usually within 24 hours. No repairs, no commissions.
Sources
- Texas Tax Code chapter 41 (sections 41.41, 41.43, 41.44, 41.461): statutes.capitol.texas.gov
- Dallas Central Appraisal District: dallascad.org
- Collin Central Appraisal District: collincad.org
- Dallas Central Appraisal District, "How do I file my protest using uFile?": support.dallascad.org
